MEX: Aeroméxico flight AM2431

[monchavo]

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-latin-america-45027112

Aeroméxico flight AM2431 has crashed.

[monchavo]

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Djdxc15XoAAszWg.jpg

[3WE]

1. So, we have crashed a Regional E-170.

2. We do not crash RJ's very often.

3. And apparently we didn't kill anyone (also consistent with the amazing RJ record).

4. I blame Embraer.

Tomfoolery aside- comments 2 and 3 (and 1) are mostly serious.

[Not_Karl]

Veered off -and overran- runway. N_K's professional, expert, credential certified, insider theory: RTO after a couple of Vs, but before 3VBS, with antiskid-less autobraking pumping 3000PSI to the brakes. There, I'm confident I solved it. But, of course, meteorite, missile, cowboyism and inexperienced PICs with less than 10K hours should Not_be discarded yet.

[3WE]

Veered off -and overran- runway. N_K's professional, expert, credential certified, insider theory: RTO after a couple of Vs, but before 3VBS, with antiskid-less autobraking pumping 3000PSI to the brakes. There, I'm confident I solved it. But, of course, meteorite, missile, cowboyism, CIA and/or Obama involvement and inexperienced PICs with less than 10K hours should Not_be discarded yet.

Fixed.

[3WE]

As noted by Not_Karl, this is the second recent incident of pilots using V-3bs to abort, run off the end, break the airplane but not_kill anyone.

I glad to see that pilots are starting to use V-3bs and that it is saving lives.

Next up: phugoid training for all.

[monchavo]

To paraphrase a person who claims to be an eyewitness

"the plane was taking off in high wind... the plane was pushed to the ground, the engines struck the runway, both engines "fell off", the plane then crashed"

[3WE]

Shall we close this out- Monchie's description + the storm and good ole wind shear seems likely...

Or do we need to use Occam's razor since getting smacked by a meteor is a very simple mechanism?

[Not_Karl]

Shall we close this out- Monchie's description + the storm and good ole wind shear seems likely...

Or do we need to wait for the final report?

Fixed.
Why did you discardeded a forgotten control lock so soon?

[3WE]

Why did you discardeded a forgotten control lock so soon?

Because of my phugoid credentials of thousands of posts at multiple parlour-talking aviation fora. Because you question my credentials, I say go to Not_Hell to you and I am done with this thread- you have no idea what it is like to sit in a fixed chair in a basement with a toy yoke and turn final in a 750,000 lb virtual 747...

And, because it seems like it maneuvered down the runway, rotated, took flight and stayed greasy side down

(or do we call that underslung-engine-side-down when we try to pass ourselves off as aviation safety experts?).

[monchavo]

Does strike me as odd that the airframe would travel that far if the engines really did "fall off".