Tip Tanks
Moderators: FrankM, el, Dmmoore
-
- ISGPOTM, 2nd only to Capt. Chesley "Sully" Sullenberger
- Posts: 1444
- Joined: Fri Feb 01, 2008 10:26 pm
Tip Tanks
I've told everyone before about the Navion that crashed when I was younger.
Last night my friend crashed in the same exact scenerio--feeding off the tip tanks for T/O on a Bonnanza and ended up the same--two broken backs from spinal compression. Both hit flat.
In both cases the tip tanks were after market additions. I now am of the opinion that they are crap because they are easily mismanged.
My friends in the Navion lived for a week prior until both died. I really hope that this one ends differntly.
I have stated it before but I will again. Everyone needs to understand thier fuel system and use it correctly.
Last night my friend crashed in the same exact scenerio--feeding off the tip tanks for T/O on a Bonnanza and ended up the same--two broken backs from spinal compression. Both hit flat.
In both cases the tip tanks were after market additions. I now am of the opinion that they are crap because they are easily mismanged.
My friends in the Navion lived for a week prior until both died. I really hope that this one ends differntly.
I have stated it before but I will again. Everyone needs to understand thier fuel system and use it correctly.
Aviation Pilot, Author, Genius
- Dmmoore
- 08/12/1946 - 06/05/2009 Rest In Peace
- Posts: 1002
- Joined: Mon Feb 04, 2008 3:07 pm
- Location: Prescott, AZ. USA
Re: Tip Tanks
Charles,
I have installed Brittan / Norman tip tanks on several different Bonanza's and two Navions. These installations were accomplished in the 60's so a current installation may be different but both installations (Bonanza and Navion) the tip tanks are placarded "Not for use during takeoff and landing".
The non Range-master (North American / Ryan built) Navions main tanks cross feed together so the fuel feed valve is on and off, not a tank selector valve. To feed from the tip tanks the tip selector is selected to Left or Right and the main tank fuel valve is turned off.
The Bonanza got a new 5 position valve. Fuel feeds only from the tank selected.
Hopefully your friend will recover fully.
I have installed Brittan / Norman tip tanks on several different Bonanza's and two Navions. These installations were accomplished in the 60's so a current installation may be different but both installations (Bonanza and Navion) the tip tanks are placarded "Not for use during takeoff and landing".
The non Range-master (North American / Ryan built) Navions main tanks cross feed together so the fuel feed valve is on and off, not a tank selector valve. To feed from the tip tanks the tip selector is selected to Left or Right and the main tank fuel valve is turned off.
The Bonanza got a new 5 position valve. Fuel feeds only from the tank selected.
Hopefully your friend will recover fully.
Don
As accomplished by managers around the world
READY - FIRE - AIM!
As accomplished by managers around the world
READY - FIRE - AIM!
- ZeroAltitude
- Posts: 1367
- Joined: Sat Feb 02, 2008 10:35 am
- Location: 127.0.0.1
Re: Tip Tanks
Sorry to hear about your friend/s.
That sucks!
I hope he/they make a full recovery.
That sucks!
I hope he/they make a full recovery.
LOL100% incorrect Ever hear of Ferry Permit? issued for Non airworthy aircraftno such thing as "barely airworthy" it's either Airworthy or Notyou still have to find a crew willing to fly this "barely airworthy" heap
Re: Tip Tanks
Tough question Shadey:
Why was this the tip-tanks fault?
I can follow you on composites, but, aside from some additional fuel management procedures, the tanks main "action" is to hold extra avgas....
That should not be a hazard.
Why was this the tip-tanks fault?
I can follow you on composites, but, aside from some additional fuel management procedures, the tanks main "action" is to hold extra avgas....
That should not be a hazard.
Commercial Pilot, Vandelay Industries, Inc., Plant Nutrient Division.
- VectorForFood
- Posts: 859
- Joined: Fri Mar 07, 2008 1:49 am
Re: Tip Tanks
Sorry to hear about your friends Shadey.
I also hope they make a full recovery and get flying again too!
I also hope they make a full recovery and get flying again too!
-
- ISGPOTM, 2nd only to Capt. Chesley "Sully" Sullenberger
- Posts: 1444
- Joined: Fri Feb 01, 2008 10:26 pm
Re: Tip Tanks
The Tip Tanks I am speaking of were modifications, not original equipment.
The flaw in them is they have no boost pumps and as Don stated cannot be used for T/O or landing. Thus they are a cruise tank.
In both cases I know what happened. They flew in and landed on the tip tanks, then on the next T/O remained on the tip tanks. In one case every fuel tank on the airplane was full, in the other they weren't.
When I began to fly complex airplanes I learned GUMP Check entereing dowwind; of which the "G" was Gas.
Gas meant boost pumps, fuel levels, fuel selector valve. If you did it every time it set you up for the next T/O, even though it is important to do a complete T/O check prior to every T/O.
So although I acknowledge there were procedural errors as the root cause in both cases, the inherent flaw in the design of the mod is that an error manifest itself in the most critical phase of flight and procedurally rears its head in a systematic fashion and the consquences are to great for the 12 glallon extra fuel for cruise.
These two accidents were almost complety identical.
The flaw in them is they have no boost pumps and as Don stated cannot be used for T/O or landing. Thus they are a cruise tank.
In both cases I know what happened. They flew in and landed on the tip tanks, then on the next T/O remained on the tip tanks. In one case every fuel tank on the airplane was full, in the other they weren't.
When I began to fly complex airplanes I learned GUMP Check entereing dowwind; of which the "G" was Gas.
Gas meant boost pumps, fuel levels, fuel selector valve. If you did it every time it set you up for the next T/O, even though it is important to do a complete T/O check prior to every T/O.
So although I acknowledge there were procedural errors as the root cause in both cases, the inherent flaw in the design of the mod is that an error manifest itself in the most critical phase of flight and procedurally rears its head in a systematic fashion and the consquences are to great for the 12 glallon extra fuel for cruise.
These two accidents were almost complety identical.
Aviation Pilot, Author, Genius
Re: Tip Tanks
Frightening similarities also reveal themselves over and over in crashes with:These two accidents were almost complety identical.
-Takeoffs with mis-rigged controls (I know, this personally affects you)
-Stalling out of base to final turns with a tail wind.
-Continued flight into IMC without IFR currency or licensing.
-Flight into icing
-Engine-out landings
-IMC flight without vacum-powered instruments
-Botched NDB approaches
-Landing in strong gusty winds
Proper use of checklists, Situational Awareness , and competent fundamental airmanship help with many of these.
Gas: Both
Undercarriage: Down and welded
Mixture: Rich
Prop: out in front, spinning (since it only has one setting)
Commercial Pilot, Vandelay Industries, Inc., Plant Nutrient Division.
Re: Tip Tanks
That's Latent human error for ya.......The Tip Tanks I am speaking of were modifications, not original equipment.
The flaw in them is they have no boost pumps and as Don stated cannot be used for T/O or landing. Thus they are a cruise tank.
In both cases I know what happened. They flew in and landed on the tip tanks, then on the next T/O remained on the tip tanks. In one case every fuel tank on the airplane was full, in the other they weren't.
When I began to fly complex airplanes I learned GUMP Check entereing dowwind; of which the "G" was Gas.
Gas meant boost pumps, fuel levels, fuel selector valve. If you did it every time it set you up for the next T/O, even though it is important to do a complete T/O check prior to every T/O.
So although I acknowledge there were procedural errors as the root cause in both cases, the inherent flaw in the design of the mod is that an error manifest itself in the most critical phase of flight and procedurally rears its head in a systematic fashion and the consquences are to great for the 12 glallon extra fuel for cruise.
These two accidents were almost complety identical.
LOL100% incorrect Ever hear of Ferry Permit? issued for Non airworthy aircraftno such thing as "barely airworthy" it's either Airworthy or Notyou still have to find a crew willing to fly this "barely airworthy" heap
- flyboy2548m
- Posts: 4391
- Joined: Sat Feb 02, 2008 12:32 am
- Location: Ormond Beach, FL
Re: Tip Tanks
3BS, you woudn't know fundamental airmanship or proper use of checklists from a hole in the wall, so just STFU for a change.Frightening similarities also reveal themselves over and over in crashes with:
-Takeoffs with mis-rigged controls (I know, this personally affects you)
-Stalling out of base to final turns with a tail wind.
-Continued flight into IMC without IFR currency or licensing.
-Flight into icing
-Engine-out landings
-IMC flight without vacum-powered instruments
-Botched NDB approaches
-Landing in strong gusty winds
Proper use of checklists, Situational Awareness , and competent fundamental airmanship help with many of these.
Gas: Both
Undercarriage: Down and welded
Mixture: Rich
Prop: out in front, spinning (since it only has one setting)
"Lav sinks on 737 Max are too small"
-TeeVee, one of America's finest legal minds.
-TeeVee, one of America's finest legal minds.
- tds
- Posts: 937
- Joined: Tue Feb 05, 2008 1:55 pm
- Location: ...a city of Southern efficiency and Northern charm
Re: Tip Tanks
Pedantic, but not all IFR airplanes have vacuum-powered instruments.IMC flight without vacum-powered instruments
And best wishes for a speedy recovery to your friends, ITS.
- Dmmoore
- 08/12/1946 - 06/05/2009 Rest In Peace
- Posts: 1002
- Joined: Mon Feb 04, 2008 3:07 pm
- Location: Prescott, AZ. USA
Re: Tip Tanks
As a minimum, vacuum powered instruments (gyro's, VG & DG) are required for flight into IMC however, electric powered gyro's are more dependable, lighter and more expensive. Solid state gyro's are even better (even lighter and more costly ).<SNIP>-IMC flight without vacum-powered instruments
I converted the vacuum powered gyro's to electric power many years ago. I did it because it saved a few pounds (7 if I remember correctly) and I found a set of overhauled gyro's (removed from a Cessna 421 that had a was being converted to use a flight director system) for a reasonable price ($2,500 for both). The conversion eliminated the vacuum pump, pressure regulator, filter housing and associated plumbing.
Vacuum powered gyro's are fine for aircraft flown either VFR or where limited IFR flight is required. I recommend electric or electronic gyro's for any aircraft where IFR flight is intended to be a part of the normal flight operations.
Don
As accomplished by managers around the world
READY - FIRE - AIM!
As accomplished by managers around the world
READY - FIRE - AIM!
Re: Tip Tanks
IMC flight after the loss of the instruments often powered by vacum.....therePedantic, but not all IFR airplanes have vacuum-powered instruments.IMC flight without vacum-powered instruments
And best wishes for a speedy recovery to your friends, ITS.
Commercial Pilot, Vandelay Industries, Inc., Plant Nutrient Division.
Re: Tip Tanks
I know that you have a rule that only ATP's can post here, and that the posts should be stuff like Concur and Indeed, but I claim to know what the GUMP checlist is from a hole in the wall (including the traditional version for retractable gear and constant speed prop.)3BS, you woudn't know fundamental airmanship or proper use of checklists from a hole in the wall, so just STFU for a change.Gas: Both
Undercarriage: Down and welded
Mixture: Rich
Prop: out in front, spinning (since it only has one setting)
I may be a dumbass...just not a total dumbass- but that concept is a bit too complex for you to understand in your black and white world.
Commercial Pilot, Vandelay Industries, Inc., Plant Nutrient Division.
- flyboy2548m
- Posts: 4391
- Joined: Sat Feb 02, 2008 12:32 am
- Location: Ormond Beach, FL
Re: Tip Tanks
Good for you. Keep your "partial dumbass" garbage to yourself. Have you not spent enough years wasting bandwidth?I may be a dumbass...just not a total dumbass...
"Lav sinks on 737 Max are too small"
-TeeVee, one of America's finest legal minds.
-TeeVee, one of America's finest legal minds.
- tds
- Posts: 937
- Joined: Tue Feb 05, 2008 1:55 pm
- Location: ...a city of Southern efficiency and Northern charm
Re: Tip Tanks
You mean, traditionally powered by vacuum?IMC flight after the loss of the instruments often powered by vacum.....there
- tds
- Posts: 937
- Joined: Tue Feb 05, 2008 1:55 pm
- Location: ...a city of Southern efficiency and Northern charm
Re: Tip Tanks
Is it mandatory to exhaust the tip tanks before switching to mains?Hey baby, nice tip tanks.
- flyboy2548m
- Posts: 4391
- Joined: Sat Feb 02, 2008 12:32 am
- Location: Ormond Beach, FL
Re: Tip Tanks
Depends on the setup.Is it mandatory to exhaust the tip tanks before switching to mains?
"Lav sinks on 737 Max are too small"
-TeeVee, one of America's finest legal minds.
-TeeVee, one of America's finest legal minds.
- Dmmoore
- 08/12/1946 - 06/05/2009 Rest In Peace
- Posts: 1002
- Joined: Mon Feb 04, 2008 3:07 pm
- Location: Prescott, AZ. USA
Re: Tip Tanks
Tip tanks installed by STC (after market) typically feed fuel from the lowest point. Typical usage would be:Is it mandatory to exhaust the tip tanks before switching to mains?Hey baby, nice tip tanks.
Takeoff and initial climb = Main tank(s(.
Cruise = Burn tip fuel, switch back to mains.
Approach and land = Main tank(s).
Aircraft like older twin Cessna's use tip tanks as mains. They are unrestricted.
Some aircraft are restricted to landing's with tip tanks empty.
Don
As accomplished by managers around the world
READY - FIRE - AIM!
As accomplished by managers around the world
READY - FIRE - AIM!
Re: Tip Tanks
Thanks, I'll try that out tonight.Takeoff and initial climb = Main tank(s(.
Cruise = Burn tip fuel, switch back to mains.
Approach and land = Main tank(s).
"I'm putting an end to this f*ckery." - Rayna Boyanov
Re: Tip Tanks
Try: Historically!You mean, traditionally powered by vacuum?IMC flight after the loss of the instruments often powered by vacum.....there
LOL100% incorrect Ever hear of Ferry Permit? issued for Non airworthy aircraftno such thing as "barely airworthy" it's either Airworthy or Notyou still have to find a crew willing to fly this "barely airworthy" heap
-
- ISGPOTM, 2nd only to Capt. Chesley "Sully" Sullenberger
- Posts: 1444
- Joined: Fri Feb 01, 2008 10:26 pm
Re: Tip Tanks
The reason they are unrestricted is that they use boost pumps unlike the mod tanks which don't.
Aircraft like older twin Cessna's use tip tanks as mains. They are unrestricted.
.
Earlies model of 310 I flew was a B Model and newest were some of the last made for American Flyers. There was a high and low boost pump setting. High was for T/O and landings. Low was for cruise.
Which reminds me of a certain AD.com member who called the Cessna 310 a "tricky beast".
Pretty funny stuff.
Aviation Pilot, Author, Genius
Re: Tip Tanks
Perhaps there were a number of incidents where pilots upgraded from something like a 172 and had some classical, often repeated issues with stuff like speed, engine failures and retractable landing gear?Which reminds me of a certain AD.com member who called the Cessna 310 a "tricky beast".
I have heard the 310 referred to as "hot". Of course that is a relative judgement.
Commercial Pilot, Vandelay Industries, Inc., Plant Nutrient Division.
-
- ISGPOTM, 2nd only to Capt. Chesley "Sully" Sullenberger
- Posts: 1444
- Joined: Fri Feb 01, 2008 10:26 pm
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests