I must admit that i have lost track in thta thread. Very long and technical posts for my short attention span and ignorance.... Of course, the latter is not much of an obstacle as ignorance has never prevented (and will never prevent) me from speaking
, so here I go:
What I have deduced until now:
-Flying a plane with an MELed ELAC is almost like flying it with a MELed wing... Or half of its engines, in Gabie's example to Evanie. Situation on single and three-engined planes is not very clear in this case.
-Pilots are at an increased risk of a TOTAL AIR DISASTER!!! if they lose both ELACs.
"
Our" (ignorant, asshat parlour talking outsiders) opinion: I agree, any failure in a plane can distract/confuse the crew and enhance their burning-hole-in-the-ground-making abilities. Even a burnt out light in the panel...
But if the pilots are not able to keep them flying when computerized systems fail
(and the plane being in a flyable condition, of course), they should
NEVER fly them and be subjected to
intense physical punishment.
Of course, computers, made by humans, will continue to explode; pilots, presumably being humans, will continue to screw up and I, from the peace, comfort, ignorance and fast-live-or-dead-decision-making-lack of my chair, will continue to judge them.
Expect (or not) more comments on the matter when (if..) I finish to read it.
POPCORN:
Well, I think we have a technology problem here: I have an old, non ELAC (or GLAC) equipped gas stovetop. Temperature gauges are MELed, so I set the burner to a known setting, use a known thickness pot and carefully monitor the situation (i.e.: hear the popping and watch for smoke or burnt smell), making slight heat adjustments if needed, until popping is done.
You, on the other hand, with a computer assisted corn-popper, are used to it making all the work and at an increased risk of a TOTAL CORN DISASTER!!! when the systems fail. The confusion and/or panic of a new, unexpected corn-popping envelope could induce you to take tragic and seemingly illogical actions, like removing the lid before the popping is done, increasing the heat to the maximum even when you see smoke coming out, cutting the power before the popping has even started, etc.
International Ban ALL Aeroplanies Association, founder and president.
"I think, based on the types of aircraft listed, you're pretty much guaranteed a fiery death."
- Contemporary Poet flyboy2548m to a Foffie.